Print TestsNewBook online, track your inspection and download reportsOpen the client portal

Print Tests

Will the Print Hold Up? Tape, Rub and Page-Count Checks for Printed Products

Printing defects rarely show at a glance. A cover looks perfect in the factory and arrives with the logo flaking at the edges, ink rubbed onto the shelf, or a notebook that is two sheets short. Most of these problems can be caught on site in a few minutes, with tape, a cloth and some alcohol, if the inspector knows what to test and the buyer has said what a pass looks like. This guide follows one of our inspectors through the three checks we run on printed notebooks, and explains how to set the same checks for packaging, stationery, labels and other printed goods.

What this article covers
  • The tape test for ink adhesion, and the cross-cut version for coatings
  • The alcohol rub and damp-cloth rub tests for rub resistance
  • Page count and print quality checks
  • Sample sizes, defect classes and what to write in your checklist

The photos come from an inspection of printed notebooks. You can watch the three tests in full, unedited, in our video Will the Print Hold Up? 3 On-Site Tests for Printed Notebooks.

Why Printing Fails After Shipment

Ink that lifts or rubs off is almost always a process problem, not bad luck. The usual causes:

None of these shows on a visual check of a fresh product. They show when the print is stressed, which is what the following tests do.

Test 1: Tape Test for Ink Adhesion

The tape test answers one question: is the ink bonded to the surface, or only resting on it? The inspector presses a strip of pressure-sensitive tape firmly over the printed area, waits briefly, then pulls it off in one quick movement and looks at both the tape and the print.

A strip of transparent tape pressed over the printed title of a hardcover agenda during a tape adhesion test
Step 1: the tape is pressed firmly over the printed title, across text, solid colour and the edge of the label.
An SSTI inspector pulling a strip of tape off a printed notebook cover in one movement
Step 2: the tape is pulled off quickly at a sharp angle; both the tape and the cover are checked for lifted ink.

How we run it when the buyer has no method of their own:

Cross-cut tape test for coatings. On painted or coated hard surfaces, such as metal, rigid plastic or glass, a simple tape pull is often too easy to pass. The stricter version first cuts a lattice through the coating with a multi-blade cutter, then applies and pulls the tape, and grades the amount of coating removed. The two common methods are ASTM D3359 (Method B, the cross-cut, for coatings up to 125 µm; Method A, an X-cut, for thicker coatings) and ISO 2409, which sets the cut spacing by coating thickness and substrate: 1 mm, 2 mm or 3 mm.

Cross-cut classification: ASTM D3359 and ISO 2409
Area removedASTM D3359ISO 2409
None; cut edges smooth5B0
Less than 5%4B1
5% – 15%3B2
15% – 35%2B3
35% – 65%1B4
More than 65%0B5

Many buyers require 4B or better (ISO class 0 or 1) on consumer products. Whatever you choose, write the class in your checklist; “good adhesion” cannot be judged on site.

Test 2: Alcohol Rub for Rub Resistance

A notebook cover is handled every day; packaging is wiped, scanned and stacked; household products are cleaned with sprays that contain alcohol. The alcohol rub test simulates all of that in less than a minute.

An SSTI inspector rubbing the printed cover of a notebook with a white cloth moistened with alcohol
The print is rubbed back and forth with a white cloth moistened with alcohol.
A white cloth being rubbed over the foil-stamped title of a weekly planner during a rub test
Foil stamping and the printed cover are rubbed with the white cloth; afterwards the cloth is checked for colour or gold that has come off.

There is no single industry standard for an on-site alcohol rub: brands set their own concentration, load and number of strokes. When the buyer has no method, a common setup, and the one in our video, is:

Damp-cloth and dry rub. For products that will never meet alcohol, a rub with a cloth dampened with water is the usual check, and many of our reports list it as “rub the printed area with a damp cloth and inspect for smudging, peeling or fading”. A dry rub with a clean cloth catches print that has not dried. Laboratory methods exist for buyers who need a measured result: ASTM D5264 tests the abrasion resistance of printed materials on a Sutherland rub tester, and ASTM D5402 assesses the solvent resistance of coatings with solvent rubs. These are not run on a factory floor.

Test 3: Page Count and Print Quality

A notebook sold as 80 sheets should have 80 sheets. Two missing sheets cannot be seen from the outside, and on a large order they add up to real money, or to a complaint from a retailer who counts. The inspector counts the sheets of a sample of notebooks and checks the inside print at the same time.

Fanning the pages of a spiral planner to count the sheets and check the printed month tabs on the page edge
Sheets are counted page by page; printed edge tabs, rounded corners and inside print are checked on the same pieces.

Sample Sizes for Print Tests

Visual print defects, such as smudges, misregistration and colour, are counted in the normal workmanship sample, usually general inspection level II. The tape and rub tests mark or damage the piece and take time, so they are run on a smaller sample drawn with a special inspection level, typically S-3 or S-4. In one of our reports on 4,000 pieces, the tape test and the rub test were each run on 32 pieces at level S-4, with AQL 0 / 0.65 / 1.5, which allows no critical defect, no major defect and one minor defect. Page counts are often done on the same smaller sample, with weighing used for the rest. How special levels and AQL work is explained in our article on ANSI/ASQ Z1.4 vs ISO 2859-1.

Classifying Print Defects

Typical classification of print defects (to be confirmed in your checklist)
ClassExamples
CriticalMissing or wrong safety warning, age grading or legal marking; wrong product or wrong language version printed
MajorInk lifts in the tape test; print fades or transfers in the rub test; logo or text misprinted or illegible; colour clearly different from the approved sample; barcode does not scan; sheet count short
MinorSmall speck or spot not visible at arm's length; slight misregistration; light scuff on a non-display surface; specks lifted only at a cut edge

How to build a full list for your product is covered in critical, major and minor defects.

Put It in Your Checklist

Most arguments about print tests are about method, not results: the factory says “we tested it”, the inspector used a stronger tape. Agree these points before the inspection:

Our guide to preparing an inspection checklist shows how to lay this out, and on-site tests during inspection covers tests for other product types.

Carton marks, barcodes and labels have their own checks; see packaging, labelling and carton mark inspection.

What On-Site Tests Cannot Replace

A tape test and a rub test show whether the print is bonded and durable on the day of the inspection. They do not show what is in the ink. Heavy metals in children's products, ink migration on food-contact items and chemical limits under rules such as California Proposition 65 need a laboratory test on a sample sent from the factory. See Prop 65 and RoHS: inspection versus lab testing and kitchenware and food-contact inspection.

Sources

Standards change. Check the current edition before writing it into a contract.

Add print tests to your next inspection

Write the tape, rub and page-count requirements under special requirements when you book, or upload your checklist afterwards.

Book an inspection

Back to Insights

Book online